Member since Apr 23, 2016



  • No friends yet.
Become My Friend Find friends »

Recent Comments

Re: “What If...

Where were CNN and MSNBC?

And, yes, focusing on Trump is a distraction.

Second quarter growth will likely be over 4% maybe as high as 4.8% the first such over 4% growth quarter in 4 years. Something all of the liberal "credible" economists have been screaming is impossible without raging inflation. Yet, the implicit inflation rate in five year inflation adjusted bonds is 2%. Full time jobs are increasing at a 3.7 million annual pace up from 1.56 million in 2016.

Yes indeed, let's focus on policy and results instead of the freak show which is about to get even freakier yet if that can be believed.

14 likes, 41 dislikes
Posted by jhuppent@hotmail.com on 07/23/2018 at 7:57 AM

Re: “"Hey Buddy, Can You Spare $200 Million?" If Your Buddy Is the Walton (Walmart) Family, Then, Yes

All of this generosity may or may not be good for the charter school movement. However, clearly many of these organizations have become dependent on the Walton Foundation for their operating expenses.

That means that every cockamamie idea that the Walton Think tank comes up with has prominence. It also means that none of these organizations can survive in a free market where you have to live on the revenues derived from student attendance- perpetual children living in the Walton basement.

The Walton Foundation has this concept of "All A's." That you can get rid of all the B through D schools and everything will be hunky dory. The state charter board has expressed this accountability concept through a convoluted equation that uses, reuses and uses again the same data to achieve a superficial sophistication.

They have also become a regulatory morass with well over forty different approvals that charter schools have to obtain in a whole variety of situations.

In difficult situations, each one of these approvals could kill a charter school. The Walton foundation has been an intellectual driving force behind "approval culture."

For example, charter schools have to seek permission from the state charter board to add students. Otherwise, they don't get paid for those students. Numerous schools have lost money because the state board couldn't get that approval on their agenda on time.

This is so bizarre it seems straight out of fiction.

The state legislature has been asleep at the switch.

0 likes, 13 dislikes
Posted by jhuppent@hotmail.com on 07/19/2018 at 9:07 AM

Re: “It Takes a Billion To Raise a Charter School Movement

The Walton Family Foundation is on a mission to save millions of minority children and children from poverty.

You continue to look at us with a straight face and tell us that everything is fine and will be fine with our district education system. All we need are a few more cycles of education reform dreamed up by the Gates Foundation, our Colleges of Education and our Think Tanks.

Unfortunately, the Walton Family Foundation has a think tank and, like the Gates Foundation, spews forth toxic ideas for education.

Policy makers will dance to any tune if it is a condition for getting grants.

We now have another spectacular policy failure from the Gates Foundation as you documented a few days ago- years after the failure took place and still remains in place doing its damage.

The Walton Think tank has its toxic failures too, just nobody has noticed them yet.

People who analyze the effect of culture on society have a saying: fish will be the last to discover water.

The Gates Foundation and the Walton Foundation still haven't discovered water.

1 like, 13 dislikes
Posted by jhuppent@hotmail.com on 07/19/2018 at 8:20 AM

Re: “Freedom Center's Philosophy 101 Course Is On the TUSD Board Agenda

This will be sweet. The school district that honored a mass murderer by hanging his portrait up on the walll, a mass murderer who shot 14,000 Hispanics in the back of the head, will be denying students the opportunity to learn about Plato giving us the mission to pursue truth and the good.

Tucson has fewer residents than it did ten years ago.

This fall,TUSD wil have 15,000 fewer students than it did 18 years ago.

Only ten percent of its parents rate Tucson an excellent place to raise a child.


Ten years from now,all these statements will still be true.

Every one is good for something. Tucson serves Arizona well as a bad example.

1 like, 38 dislikes
Posted by jhuppent@hotmail.com on 07/10/2018 at 11:00 PM

Re: “Arizona Earns an F. Merit Pay Fails. DeVos-Backed Company Caught Lying.

Any educational experiment that produces the teacher attrition and vacancy rates we have in Arizona is a failed experiment."

No one has ever presented any study which shows teacher attrition rates to be higher in Arizona than in other states. The only study, a huge sample done out of ASU, of teacher job satisfaction did not show lower teacher job satisfaction in Arizona.

The people who started this chant used to work for me and I saw first hand the "evidence." It was not evidence at all. Nationwide, the attrition rate for teachers (by attrition rate, I mean leaving the profession not leaving their school) has always been greater than 50% in the first five years. Arizona has a greater turnover rate than the national average because, in Arizona, unlike other states, teachers have choices of where to work, lots of choices. But, turnover isn't attrition.

4 likes, 44 dislikes
Posted by jhuppent@hotmail.com on 06/26/2018 at 11:44 AM

Re: “Arizona Earns an F. Merit Pay Fails. DeVos-Backed Company Caught Lying.

The phrase "merit pay" is meaningless in education if you don't talk about the specific design elements.

Merit pay can mean:

1) The principal decides how much to increase the pay of each teacher based on his perception of "performance." Thus, teachers are pitted against each other in a negative interdependence- the opposite of a healthy work relationship.

2) The teachers can be rewarded for the test scores of their students in a doubly brainless relationship. They are pitted against their students and subject to random feedback of test scores which are primarily a function of family SES.

3. Teachers can be rewarded for the percentage of parents rating their school district and school "excellent" creating a positive interdependent relationship between teachers and between teachers and parents. Nationwide, only 24% of parents rate their child's school excellent. Done right, this percentage can improve at 2 percentage points a year. Done perfectly, it can be improved at 7 percentile points a year.

4. Teachers can be rewarded for the academic gains of their school and school district. Done mildly and done in conjunction with a parent excellence measurement and done with strict controls of testing integrity, this can enhance the package.

5. Teachers can be subject to peer ratings, further enhancing the effectiveness of the package.

6. Student evaluations of school climate through the 7C's or Gallup's Hope Engagement and Well-being framework can be used to further enhance performance pay.

So, merit pay doesn't have to fail. It just always has- everywhere except in Arizona.

4 likes, 32 dislikes
Posted by jhuppent@hotmail.com on 06/26/2018 at 9:37 AM

Re: “Arizona Earns an F. Merit Pay Fails. DeVos-Backed Company Caught Lying.

Recently Matthew Chingos of the Urban Institute did one of the most sophisticated rankings of state academic performance ever performed. He both measured academic gains on the National Assessment of Educational Progress from 2013 4th grade to 2017 8th grade and he also took the 2017 8th grade data and adjusted it for the six demographic variables contained in the data collected by the NAEP.

Arizona finished in the top half of both measures which interestingly enough, were not correlated with each other. A fact which Chingos did no comment on.

When Chingos did his evaluation of 2015 NAEP sccores, he ranked Arizona 13th in the nation in adjusted scores and Arizona was number one in the nation in cohort gains (2011 4th grade to 2015 8th grade).

When you look internally at school districts with excellent management, Chandler Unified, Mesa Unified, Vail, etc., their internal measures of quality from the parent's perspective, i.e. the percentage of parents rating the quality of their child's school excellent, an "A" rating, or "Very Satisfied" are all well above 60%. Chandler is at 75%, up a couple of percentage points a year from 38% in 1998.

By comparison, the nation plunged from 36%, an all-time high in 2011 to 24%, essentially an all-time low in 2015. The plunge so horrified PhiDeltaKappa that they discontinued the 47 year survey, fracturing the only longitudinal data we have for quality from a parent's perspective.

The data is even more striking for social indicators. In 1992, the year before school choice started in Arizona, their were 70 murders by juveniles with an at-risk population of less than 100,000 students. By 2012, this had fallen to 7 murders with an at-risk population of more than 400,000 students. Juvenile murder rates for the nation also went down, but nowhere as much as Arizona.

In 2017, Black 8th graders in Arizona scored number one in the nation in math, outscoring African Americans in all 49 other states, up from 6th in 2000. Arizona Asian Americans placed 5th, up from 11th in 2013.

Connecticut is the epitome of education culture, spending $22,000 per year per student. Our Black 8th graders don't just outscore their Black 8th graders in math, they outscore them by a whole year and a half. Our Hispanics don't just outscore them in 8th grade math, they outscore them by an entire year's worth of progress. Our whites also outscore their white 8th graders.

What does Connecticut have to show for their $22,000? Since 2000, Connecticut has lost 14,000 jobs because of the tax load, while Arizona has added over 400,000 jobs.

The evidence is overwhelming, school choice has created enormous value for Arizona students.

7 likes, 27 dislikes
Posted by jhuppent@hotmail.com on 06/26/2018 at 6:37 AM

All Comments »

Favorite Places

  • None.
Find places »

Saved Events

  • Nada.
Find events »

Saved Stories

  • Nope.
Find stories »

Custom Lists

  • Zip.

© 2018 Tucson Weekly | 7225 Mona Lisa Rd. Ste. 125, Tucson AZ 85741 | (520) 797-4384 | Powered by Foundation